Multi-Incident Comparative Analyses    
  Printable Version of Page  
  PRINT   EMAIL   POST A COMMENT
AVERAGE RATING (1)
This page houses documents which contain information relating to multiple wildland fire incidents, escaped prescribed fires, and/or general historical analyses which would not necessarily be linked to any single incident in the Reviews and Investigations database.  
Specific Multi-Incident Wildfire Related Documents  
 
Surveillance of Mortality During the Texas Panhandle Wildfires (March 2006)  In response to the disaster, regional and state public health preparedness staff at the Texas Department of State Health Services activated mortality surveillance and initiated an investigation to describe the ...
Author: Texas Dept.of State Health Services  Published: 2006  Posted 2/6/2007

Learning From Our Mistakes, Lessons Gleaned from the 1994 Shelter Deployments in the Southwest Area and the South Canyon Fire. "An analysis of the investigation team reports for the three Southwest Area and one Colorado fire shelter deployment was conducted by A&FM Assistant Director Bill Russell. This analysis focuses on the information provided in these reports and is supplemented by some personal knowledge of areas and events." 1MB  Author: USFS Southwest Region  Published: 1994  Posted 1/10/2007  

Similarities of Fatality Fires  Following is a brief overview of the some of the key similarities of three fatality fires: South Canyon, Thirtymile, and Cramer. ... Each host fire Unit had experienced previous entrapment and/or fatality fires  74.1KB  Author: Jim Payne  Published: 2004  Posted 1/1/2004

Fire Shelter Deployment Review of 1988  700.2KB  Author: Many  Published: 1989  Posted 5/25/2004

TriData_phase1.pdf  These can be used to receive and relay images to and from the ground through an airborne link to the incident commander and/or local FMO. 714.7KB  Published: 1997  Posted 1/1/2004  
 
TriData_phase2.pdf  This report summarizes the results of Phase II of a four phase study to examine the Federal wildland firefighting community and to improve firefighter safety. ... The focus in Phase I was on systematically ...  368.6KB  Posted 1/1/2004
 
TriData phase 3 links  This document contains links to the separate chapters of the TriData Phase III study, assembled on one page for your convenience. Please click the corresponding link to access a particular section of the report. Author: LLC  Published: 2007  Posted 2/7/2007

 

Multi-Incident Prescribed Fire Related Documents
 
Firefighter in front of flames Prescribed Fire Escapes and Near Miss Lessons Learned  (610KB pdf posted 10/31/2008)
"On many of the prescribed fire escapes examined during this Information Collection Team effort, frequent problems stemmed from a lack of adequate communication and coordination between members of the burn team—in both the planning and implementation phases. One person might write the burn plan, the agency administrator approves the plan, the plan is peer-reviewed by someone in a separate location, and, finally, a burn boss arrives the day of the burn—along with some or all of the other resources—to implement the plan." This is a Lessons Learned Center Information Collection Team analysis; with a series of key findings and sand table "prompts" using the principles of High Reliability Organizing.

Prescribed Fire Lessons Learned Initial Impressions Report."This analysis is the first known attempt to take a comprehensive look at escaped prescribed fire reviews and near misses.  A total of 30 prescribed fire escape reviews and ‘near misses’ (see Appendix A and B) were analyzed to discover what, if any reoccurring lessons were being learned, or whether they were indicating emerging knowledge gaps or trends.  It is estimated that Federal land management agencies complete between 4,000 and 5,000 prescribed fires annually." 320 KB  Author: Deirdre Dether  Published: 2005  Posted 10/27/2006 
 
FWS Escaped Prescribed Fires Review Final Report Oct. 2006. "The review findings addressed key areas to be incorporated into the planning process for prescribed burns. This includes better contingency planning, increase suppression skills for firefighters participating in prescribed burns, trigger points for increasing beyond minimum staffing, and reduce the need for converting prescribed fires to wildfires due to fires burning in ground fuels." 346KB  Author: FWS  Published: 2006  Posted 1/10/2007
 

Multi-Incident Historical Comparisons and Analyses 

Wisconsin Wildland Incident Report 2004-2006 
 This is a compilation of wildland fire incidents which involved injuries (private or professional) from the state of Wisconsin for the years 2004-2006. Author: James Barnier, Wisconsin DNR  Published: 2006  Posted 2/27/2007

102_US_Firefighter_Fatalities_2002.pdf
  These fatality statistics for 2002 are provisional and subject to change as the USFA contacts State Fire Marshals at the beginning of each year to verify the names of firefighters reported to have died on-duty ...  49.8KB  Published: 2003  Posted 1/1/2004

Trends in wildland fire entrapment fatalities
  These include the U.S. Forest Service Region 5 Safety First initiative and FIRESCOPE project, Carl Wilson’s research paper titled Fatal and Near-Fatal Forest Fires – The Common Denominators, and finally the Report ...  216.2KB  Author: Jim Cook  Published: 2004  Posted 1/1/2004  
  
Entrapment_Related_Fatalities_1976_2002.pdf  During the study period, fatalities occurred during 28 incidents. ... A total of 105 fatalities were reported, about four per year.  573.8KB  Published: 2002  Posted 1/1/2004
 
1976to1999_Entrapments_Part_1.pdf  With an average of over 70 fire entrapments occurring each year, the factors affecting entrapments need to be identified and understood. ... The term entrapments includes not only entrapments, but also shelter ...  2150.6KB  Published: 2003  Posted 1/1/2004  
 
1976to1999_Entrapments_Part_2.pdf  Since 1976, 1,692 firefighter entrapments have been reported during 240 incidents (Figure 2), an average of 70 entrapments a year. ... The Forest Service was the primary employer of persons entrapped during 54 incidents, ...  133.7KB  Posted 1/1/2004

Fatalities_1990_1998sm.pdf
  Burnovers were responsible for 29% of all fatalities in the period analyzed, even though they represented just 16% of the events causing fatalities. ... Contractors working on wildland fire operations suffered ...  1346.4KB  Published: 1999  Posted 1/1/2004 

FEMA_USFA_Report1997_Fatalities.pdf
  However, wildland ground fatalities (as opposed to those occurring in aircraft) that are attributable to medical causes has previously been shown to have similar basic fatalities causes. ... Although the number of ...  49.4KB  Published: 1997  Posted 1/1/2004

Historical Wildland Fire Fatalities 1910 - 1996
  March 1997, 2nd edition This data is an attempt to document historical wildland fire fatalities from the many different wildland fire management agencies. ... This second edition includes 54 additional ... 616.3KB  Author: NWCG  Published: 1997  Posted 1/1/2004  
 
1985 Fire Entrapment Incident Review  "There were over 200 fire shelter deployments during the 1985 fire season warranting the National Wildfire Coordinating Group (NWCG) to request a review of the fire entrapments. As a result, the enclosed review was presented to the NWCG at their July meeting." Author: NWCG Jerry Monesmith, Bill Lyon, Art Jukkala  Published: 1986  Posted 2/14/2007
 
Preliminary Report of Joint Task Force on Study of Fatal/Near-Fatal Wildland Fire Accidents "During 1979 there were 15 fire-related deaths and a number of near misses experienced by Federal, State, and Canadian fire-fighting agencies. This is an increase in the trend over the last several years./ The National Wildfire Coordination Group (NWCG) established an ad hoc task force to analyze the problem, identify any common causes, and make recommendations to reduce the occurrence of this type of accident. This is the task force's report." Author: NWCG Joint Task Force  Published: 1980  Posted 2/15/2007
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2006  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2006. Author: NWCG Safety and Health Working Team  Published: 2007  Posted 2/6/2007
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2005  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2005. 60.6KB  Author: NWCG Safety & Health Working Team  Published: 2006  Posted 2/10/2006  
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2004  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2004. 106KB  Author: Safety & Health Working Team  Published: 2005  Posted 3/8/2005 
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2003  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2003. 117.5KB  Published: 2003  Posted 1/1/2004   
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2002  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2002. 119.2KB  Author: NWCG Safety & Health Working Team  Published: 2003  Posted 1/1/2004

NWCG Safety Gram 2001
 The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2001. 21.6KB  Author: Stan Palmer Posted 1/1/2004
 
NWCG Safety Gram 2000  The NWCG Safety & Health Working Team list of wildland firefighter serious accidents and fatalities for the year 2000.  23.5KB  Author: Stan Palmer Posted 1/1/2004
 
NWCG Safety Grams 1987 to 1996  This is a collection of NWCG Safety Grams from 1987 to 1996.
Author: NWCG Satety and Health Working Team  Published: 1996  Posted 2/14/2007 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Comments

Rating Edit Delete
The posting of the lessons_gleaned_from_1994_shelter_deployments is missing the attachments, I would particulary like to read apendix f, have we learned anything from battlement creek.
Posted by:  on 12/2/2007
 
Disclaimer: Information is provided with the intent to share knowledge to improve safety, performance, efficiency and organizational learning throughout the entire wildland fire community. However, no warranties or guarantees are implied because much of the data provided is beyond the control of the Center. No endorsement of any company or product is given or implied.